Best Ice Cream Shops in Charlottesville
Charlottesville, Virginia — updated April 17, 2026
Discover the best ice cream shops in Charlottesville with our curated guide to local favorites.
1. SugarBear Gourmet Ice Cream
Located at 1522 E High St, SugarBear Gourmet Ice Cream has quickly become a standout in the Charlottesville ice cream scene. With a solid rating of 4.4 out of 5 from 59 reviews, this artisanal ice cream shop is celebrated for its handcrafted flavors. The expert notes, "SugarBear’s handcrafted ice creams bear incredibly unique and dynamic/fresh flavorings that span the palette of young and old, especially those with a witty sense of humor." This is a place where creativity meets quality, making it one of the most exciting additions to the local dessert landscape.
When visiting SugarBear, be sure to try their innovative ice creams that often feature quirky flavor combinations. The ambiance is laid-back, making it perfect for a casual outing with friends or family. With outdoor seating available, you can enjoy your ice cream while soaking in the charm of Charlottesville. Don't miss out on their unique, handcrafted ice creams which are a must-try for any visitor!
2. Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge
Nestled in the heart of Charlottesville’s Downtown Mall at 313 E Main St, Kilwins Ice Cream is more than just an ice cream shop; it’s a full-fledged experience. With a commendable rating of 4.5 out of 5 from 190 reviews, Kilwins offers a delightful selection of ice creams, chocolates, and fudge. An expert describes it perfectly: "This independently owned ice cream & candy shop provides delicious treats such as toffee, chocolate, and caramel to customers on Charlottesville’s Downtown Mall." The inviting atmosphere encourages repeat visits, as the friendly staff and high-quality products never disappoint.
As you step into Kilwins, the aroma of freshly made waffle cones is sure to entice you. Make sure to try their ice cream, fudge, and chocolates for a complete indulgence. The cozy interior is perfect for a quick stop, and their outdoor seating allows you to enjoy your treats while people-watching on the bustling mall. Whether you're in the mood for a classic sundae or some decadent chocolates, Kilwins is a must-visit.
3. La Flor Michoacana
For a unique twist on traditional ice cream, La Flor Michoacana at 601A Cherry Ave is the place to be. With an impressive rating of 4.7 out of 5 from 479 reviews, this shop specializes in authentic Mexican paletas. An expert shares, "We love their Oreo Cookie and Mango paletas and visiting their main colorful location or the Farmers Market at Ix while enjoying a nice stroll." The paletas, crafted with fresh ingredients, strike a perfect balance of sweetness, making them an ideal treat on a hot day.
The vibrant atmosphere at La Flor Michoacana adds to the experience, with colorful decor that reflects its Mexican roots. Be sure to try their blackberry cheesecake, passion fruit, and strawberry milk paletas, which are all crowd favorites. The shop is perfect for a casual visit, and their presence at local farmers' markets means you can enjoy these delicious treats while exploring the community. It’s an experience that should not be missed!
4. Ben & Jerry’s
Located at 1112 Emmet St N, Ben & Jerry’s is a household name that has found a loving home in Charlottesville. With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 from 312 reviews, this iconic ice cream shop is beloved for its variety of flavors and commitment to quality. An expert notes, "We love that they offer non-dairy options in addition to our classic favorites (Cherry Garcia, anyone?)." This makes it an inclusive spot for all ice cream lovers, including those with dietary restrictions.
The ambiance at Ben & Jerry’s is friendly and welcoming, making it a great spot for families and friends alike. The menu features an extensive selection of flavors, from classic sundaes to shakes and pints. Be sure to try the classic Cherry Garcia, which has become a fan favorite. With both indoor and outdoor seating, you can enjoy your ice cream while taking in the sights of the surrounding area. This is a must-stop for anyone craving a rich and creamy treat!
5. Moo Thru Charlottesville
If you're looking for ice cream made with love and natural ingredients, Moo Thru Charlottesville is the place to visit. Situated at 946 Grady Ave, this shop boasts a solid rating of 4 out of 5 from 105 reviews. An expert describes it best: "Moo Thru brings the deliciousness of their original shop on 29 North (near Culpepper) to the center of Charlottesville." As a family-run business, their commitment to quality is evident in every scoop.
The atmosphere at Moo Thru is relaxed and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for families. Their slow-churned ice cream, made from all-natural ingredients, is a standout, and you won't want to miss their Blackberry Cobbler and Mint Oreo flavors. The shop has a cozy interior, and outdoor seating allows you to enjoy your ice cream while taking in the fresh Virginia air. Moo Thru is a local gem that highlights the importance of quality ingredients and family traditions.
6. Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard
For a nostalgic ice cream experience, head to Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard at 1881 Seminole Trail. With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 from 463 reviews, this shop is known for its creamy custard and retro vibe. An expert shares, "From the black and white photographs to the children’s merry-go-round, Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard has the right custard for each customer." The atmosphere is reminiscent of classic ice cream parlors, making it a delightful stop for all ages.
At Kohr Brothers, you'll find a variety of custard options, including coffee custard and delicious milkshakes. The friendly staff is always ready to help you pick the perfect treat, whether you're in the mood for a classic or something new. The charming decor and outdoor seating create a perfect environment for enjoying your sweet treats. Make sure to stop by for a taste of nostalgia and a scoop of delicious custard!
7. Thai '99 II Restaurant & Bar
For those seeking an exotic twist on ice cream, Thai '99 II at 915 Gardens Blvd is a must-visit. With a rating of 4.4 out of 5 from 505 reviews, this restaurant offers a unique menu that includes creamy ice cream desserts with exotic Thai flavors. An expert notes, "Indulge in creamy ice cream desserts. Try our exotic Thai flavors." This makes it an ideal choice for adventurous eaters looking to explore new tastes.
The ambiance at Thai '99 II is vibrant and inviting, perfect for enjoying a meal followed by dessert. Their ice cream options include traditional Burmese scoops and a variety of Thai flavors that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The restaurant accommodates both vegetarian and gluten-free options, allowing everyone to enjoy their offerings. It’s a great spot to experience something different in the Charlottesville ice cream landscape!
8. Carter Mountain Orchard and Country Store
A visit to Carter Mountain Orchard and Country Store at 1435 Carters Mountain Trail is not just about the ice cream; it’s about the experience. With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 from 4308 reviews, this location is famous for its breathtaking views and delicious soft serve. An expert recommends, "The soft serve will win you over on a hot day." The orchard provides a picturesque backdrop for enjoying a cool treat.
The soft serve here is a must-try, especially their vanilla ice cream and seasonal peach flavor. The setting is perfect for family outings, and the seasonal offerings make it an exciting stop throughout the year. With ample outdoor seating, you can savor your ice cream while enjoying the stunning mountain views. Carter Mountain is a place where sweet treats meet beautiful scenery!
Final Recommendations
Charlottesville's ice cream scene is as diverse as its community, offering everything from classic flavors to innovative treats. Whether you're in the mood for handcrafted ice cream at SugarBear, traditional paletas at La Flor Michoacana, or unique Thai flavors at Thai '99 II, there’s something for everyone. So grab your friends and family, and embark on a delicious adventure to sample the best ice cream shops Charlottesville has to offer!