Best Pizza in Charlottesville
Charlottesville, Virginia — updated August 22, 2026
Neapolitan pies near JPA, a late bar menu on Monticello Road, New York slices downtown and a wood-fired truck, ranked by how settled their ratings are.
Listings verified
Charlottesville's pizza splits cleanly into two camps: Neapolitan pies from wood or gas-fired ovens, and New York-style slices sold by the foot near the Downtown Mall. The strongest ratings in town belong to the Neapolitan side, though the counter-service places have the longer hours and the shorter waits. Note that several of the best kitchens here close on Sunday, which catches visitors out.
1. Pi-Napo Pizzeria
The highest-rated pizzeria in the city and the best-documented: 4.9 across 1,070 reviews, a figure large enough that the score is settled rather than promising. The kitchen is on Jefferson Park Avenue, an easy walk from the hospital and UVA's south side, and it does Neapolitan-style pies alongside homemade Italian desserts and gelato. Hours are the friendliest on this list, 11:00am to 9:00pm seven days a week. Weekday lunch has its own advantage: a personal 10-inch pizza is available Monday through Friday from 11:00am to 4:00pm, which is the cheapest way to test the crust before committing to a full pie.
2. Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria
Lampo holds a 4.7 across 918 reviews, which puts it in proven territory rather than merely well-liked. It sits in Belmont on Monticello Road, in a small room that fills early and stays full. The dining room runs Wednesday through Sunday, 11:30am to 9:00pm, while the bar goes Wednesday through Saturday from 5:00pm to midnight, making this the late option in a town that mostly stops serving at nine. Third-party listings still show older lunch and dinner hours, so check before a midweek trip. Walk-in waits are the norm at peak dinner.
3. Vita Nova New York Style Pizza & Restaurant
The downtown answer for New York-style slices, at 321 E Main Street on the Mall, with a 4.7 rating across 287 reviews. That is a solid sample, enough to trust, if a third of Lampo's. Beyond plain cheese pies in large and extra-large, the menu runs to specialty pies including spinach and feta. Hours are Monday through Thursday and Saturday, 11:00am to 8:00pm, with Friday running an hour later to 9:00pm. Closed Sunday, which matters if you are downtown on a weekend afternoon and working through options.
4. Popitos Pizza
Wood-fired Neapolitan pies from a business that started with mobile pop-ups and now works out of Rio Hill Center, north of town off Route 29. The rating is 4.6 from 132 reviews, a reasonable body of evidence and the reason this location, rather than the newer downtown counter at 200 W Water Street, is the one listed here. The downtown spot carries a perfect 5.0 but from only nine reviews, too few to mean much yet. Both run 11:00am to 8:00pm Monday through Saturday and close Sunday.
5. Christian's Pizza
A Charlottesville staple for slices, rated 4.4 from 295 reviews. The score is the lowest here, but the sample is among the largest, which makes it a dependable read rather than an outlier: consistent, widely used, not the pie that wins arguments. This is the 5th Street SW location. Worth knowing about when the Neapolitan places are at capacity or already closed for the night.
6. Crustworthy Pizza
Wood-fired sourdough pies, and the only entry here that comes to you. Founded in 2022 and based in Crozet, Crustworthy operates as a mobile pizzeria catering weddings, rehearsal dinners and private parties, with a Preston Avenue address in Charlottesville. Its 4.8 rating rests on just 40 reviews, so treat it as promising rather than established, and confirm availability directly rather than assuming a walk-up window. One documented pie combines fontina, pepperoni and basil pesto. Ranked last not on quality but because it is an event booking rather than a table you can claim on a Tuesday.
What we left off
Popitos Pizza's downtown location at 200 W Water Street was cut as a second branch of a business already on the list; nine reviews is too thin to rank it separately. Random Row Brewing Co. on Preston Avenue was removed because it is a craft brewery rather than a pizzeria, and nothing in our research establishes it as a pizza destination.