Best Pizza in Fredericksburg, Texas
Fredericksburg, Texas — updated August 21, 2026
Four Fredericksburg pizzerias ranked by what the ratings actually show, from a trattoria open daily on Lincoln Street to a highway-16 shop with a near-perfect score.
Listings verified
Fredericksburg's pizza options cluster within a few blocks of Main Street, which means the deciding factor is usually hours: some kitchens close at 8:30 p.m., one shuts down Mondays, and one runs a Sunday brunch service instead of dinner. The four below are ranked by rating weighted against how many reviews stand behind it. Nothing here is a chain, and one place from the previous version has been cut for not serving pizza at all.
1. Prometheus Pizza Trattoria
The strongest combination of score and sample size in town: 4.8 across 582 reviews, which is enough volume to treat that rating as settled rather than promising. It runs as an all-day trattoria at 108 S Lincoln St, near San Antonio Street, open every day from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., with full-service lunch from 11 to 4 and full-service dinner from 4 to 9. Because there is no day off, it is the reliable answer on a Monday, when other kitchens in the category go dark. Pepperoni by the slice appears prominently in the restaurant's own material, alongside Italian dishes beyond the pizza list.
2. EZ PZ Pizza
The highest rating in Fredericksburg at 4.9, though from 369 reviews rather than the four figures a truly proven number would carry. Call it very promising and trending well. It sits at 1003 S State Hwy 16, outside the Main Street crush, which makes parking less of an ordeal than downtown. Listings show an 11 a.m. opening with an 8 p.m. close early in the week, so this is an early-dinner stop rather than a late one. The shop describes its output as gourmet pizza, and it has occasionally closed for the day on short notice, so a call ahead is worth the trouble.
3. West End Pizza Co.
The most-reviewed pizzeria on this list by a wide margin, with more than 1,700 reviews behind a 4.2. That is a proven average rather than a fragile one: a lot of people have eaten here and landed in roughly the same place. At 207 E San Antonio St, it is the downtown default, and the menu goes well past pizza with starters, signature and build-your-own pies, pasta, salads, soups, sandwiches, desserts and a kids menu, which is why it absorbs large mixed groups. Online ordering for delivery or pickup runs to 9:30 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and to 8:30 p.m. Sunday through Thursday.
4. Pi Social
A 4.3 from 318 reviews, the smallest sample here, so the number is less settled than West End's. The Fredericksburg location at 206 N Milam St keeps the most distinctive schedule of the four: Tuesday through Thursday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., Friday and Saturday until 10 p.m., and Sunday 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. only. It is closed Mondays. Happy hour runs Tuesday through Friday from 3 to 5 p.m., and the restaurant takes reservations, which matters on weekends. There is a second Pi Social in Midland with different hours, so check you are reading the right listing.
What we left off
Woerner Cafe + Catering appeared on the previous version of this list. It is a well-regarded bakery and cafe on E Live Oak St, open Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. and closed Sundays, serving breakfast, lunch and catering. It is not a pizzeria, so it does not belong in a pizza ranking.