Best Pizza in Lynchburg
Lynchburg, Virginia — updated August 21, 2026
Discover the best pizza spots in Lynchburg with our curated guide featuring cozy atmospheres and delicious flavors.
1. Benny's Pizza - Lynchburg
Located at 1019 Main St, Benny's Pizza has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike, boasting a solid 4.5/5 rating from over 1000 reviews. The atmosphere here is cozy and welcoming, making it a perfect place to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family. As one expert noted, "Rating: 3.7/5 (102 reviews)" highlighting the restaurant's reputation among diners.
What sets Benny's apart is its thoughtful menu that caters to various tastes. You can’t go wrong with the Margherita Pizza, which features a delicious blend of fresh mozzarella, basil, and a rich tomato sauce. For meat lovers, the Pepperoni Pizza is a must-try, while the Veggie Deluxe is perfect for those looking for a flavorful, meat-free option. Each dish is crafted with quality ingredients, ensuring a satisfying dining experience.
2. Rivermont Pizza
Rivermont Pizza, located at 2496 Rivermont Ave, is another top contender with a rating of 4.5/5 from 818 reviews. This spot is particularly popular for its wide variety of toppings and sauces, making it a favorite among pizza aficionados. As an expert pointed out, "Rating: 4.1/5 (194 reviews)" emphasizes the quality and diversity of options available.
Rivermont is known for its wood-fired pizzas, which give a unique flavor that’s hard to replicate. The Bibby Pizza, topped with red sauce, pepperoni, ground beef, red onion, green peppers, and a three-cheese blend, is a standout item that many patrons rave about. Don’t forget to try their meatball appetizer to start your meal on a high note!
3. Waterstone Pizza
If you’re in the mood for a lively atmosphere along with your pizza, head over to Waterstone Pizza at 1309 Jefferson St. With an impressive rating of 4.4/5 from 1684 reviews, this restaurant is a local favorite. One expert's quote captures its essence perfectly: "Rating: 3.9/5 (436 reviews)."
The expansive menu at Waterstone features a variety of pizzas that cater to all tastes. The Pepperoni Pizza is a classic choice, while the Vegetarian Delight and BBQ Chicken Pizza offer delicious alternatives for those with different preferences. The vibrant ambiance makes it a great place to hang out, whether it’s a casual dinner or a night out with friends.
4. Upper Crust Pizza
For those seeking gourmet pizza options, Upper Crust Pizza at 102 Hexham Dr A stands out with a commendable rating of 4.6/5 from 219 reviews. This spot is recognized for its commitment to fresh ingredients and creative toppings. An expert mentions, "Rating: 4.1/5 (44 reviews)," which speaks to the quality of their offerings.
At Upper Crust, you can expect to find gourmet pizzas that take traditional favorites to the next level. The innovative flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients make each bite a delightful experience. It’s a great place for food lovers who appreciate a refined take on pizza.
5. Fratelli Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar
Located at 1200 Commerce St Suite 200, Fratelli Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar combines two beloved concepts: exquisite pizza and fine wine. With a rating of 4.1/5 from 237 reviews, it’s a unique spot where you can indulge in a delightful dining experience. An expert insight states, "Rating: 3.7/5 (50 reviews)," highlighting its appeal.
This restaurant serves brunch and dinner, making it a great choice for any meal of the day. The ambiance is sophisticated yet inviting, perfect for a date night or a casual gathering. While the menu features numerous enticing offerings, the pizza here is a must-try, making it an excellent option to pair with your favorite wine from their full bar.
6. Ledo Pizza
At 126 Old Graves Mill Rd, Ledo Pizza is celebrated for its large portions and tasty crust, achieving an impressive rating of 4.4/5 from 694 reviews. An expert highlights this by stating, "Rating: 3.4/5 (51 reviews)," which reflects its popularity among customers.
Known for its generous servings, Ledo Pizza is perfect for families or anyone with a big appetite. The crust is a standout feature, adding an extra layer of flavor to the overall pizza experience. It’s a great option for those looking to enjoy a hearty meal without breaking the bank.
7. Jo Jo Pizza Lynchburg
Last but not least, Jo Jo Pizza Lynchburg, located at 1400 Lakeside Dr, has made a name for itself with a rating of 4.2/5 from 897 reviews. An expert noted, "Rating: 3.3/5 (75 reviews)," showcasing the positive feedback from patrons.
Jo Jo Pizza is known for its great variety of toppings and friendly service, making it a great spot for families and friends. The casual atmosphere invites diners to relax and enjoy a slice of pizza tailored to their preferences, with plenty of options to choose from.
Conclusion
When it comes to finding the best pizza in Lynchburg, these local gems offer a fantastic selection that caters to every taste and preference. Whether you’re in the mood for gourmet creations or classic favorites, you can't go wrong with any of these recommendations. From the cozy ambiance of Benny's Pizza to the unique offerings at Mellow Mushroom, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Don’t forget to bring your appetite as you explore these delicious pizza places!
Updated 2026-08-21: a national chain has been removed from this guide. Guide2 covers independent local businesses — see our editorial standards.