Best Seafood in Lynchburg
Lynchburg, Virginia — updated August 21, 2026
Four places for seafood in Lynchburg, a city two hundred miles from the coast.
Listings verified
Lynchburg is a long way inland, so seafood here is a matter of intent. Four places take it seriously, and between them they cover a raw bar, a fish house, a fine-dining room and a small newcomer.
1. The Water Dog
The most-reviewed restaurant in Lynchburg and the default answer to this question: 4.4 across 1,807 reviews, downtown on Jefferson Street. Raw bar and seafood-led menu in a room that works for a casual dinner or a longer one.
2. Harbor Inn Seafood
4.4 across 1,663 reviews on Old Forest Road, and the more traditional fish house of the two leaders. Fried and blackened plates rather than a raw bar. Nearly identical rating to The Water Dog across a nearly identical number of visits, so the choice between them is about which format you want rather than which is better.
3. The Dahlia
4.5 across 504 reviews on Bedford Avenue, and the highest-rated of the four. Not a seafood restaurant as such — it is the fine-dining option that does seafood well — so it belongs here for a particular kind of evening rather than as a general recommendation.
4. Driftwood Seafood Co. & Raw Bar
The newest and smallest, 4.3 across 63 reviews. That review count is thin enough that the rating is promising rather than established, and it is included on that basis. Fresh seafood and a raw bar, on Crowell Lane.
What we left off
The previous version of this guide recommended Red Lobster and Captain D's. Both are national chains, and in a guide of three entries that left exactly one Lynchburg restaurant on a list about Lynchburg.