Best Burgers in Naples
Naples, Florida — updated August 24, 2026
From a downtown burger counter with thousands of reviews to a waterfront chickee bar on Tamiami Trail, here are the Naples restaurants whose burgers have the ratings to back them up, ranked by how settled that evidence is.
Listings verified
Naples burgers split into two camps: the downtown counters within walking distance of Fifth Avenue, and the roadside taverns and grills strung along Tamiami Trail, Davis Boulevard and Pine Ridge Road. The ranking below leans on how much evidence sits behind each rating, since a 4.5 held up across more than a thousand reviews says more than a high score from a couple of hundred. Hours in Naples shift with the season, so confirm before driving.
1. Brooks Burgers
The one place on this list that puts burgers in its name, and the one with the deepest track record: 4.7 across 2,714 reviews, which is about as settled as a rating gets in this city. It sits at 330 9th St S, downtown and close enough to the Fifth Avenue shopping blocks to walk from most of them. A count that size means the kitchen has been judged in high season and in the quiet months alike, and it has held the same number. Parking downtown is the main obstacle rather than the food. Expect company at peak meal times given the address and the volume of people who have eaten here.
2. Harold's Place Chickee Bar And Grill
Second on evidence: 4.5 from 1,269 reviews, the second-largest sample here, earned at 2555 Tamiami Trl N. The chickee bar format puts it in the open-air, order-a-beer-with-lunch category rather than the sit-down dining room category, which is worth knowing if you are choosing between the two. A rating that holds at 4.5 across that many visits is proof rather than promise. Because it is on the Trail north of downtown, it draws a mix of regulars and people who spotted it from the road, and the busiest stretch tends to be the middle of the day.
3. The Oasis
Tied with Brooks for the highest score on this list at 4.7, though from a smaller base of 454 reviews, so call it strong rather than proven. It is at 1046 Pine Ridge Rd, away from the beach traffic and easier to reach from the eastern residential neighborhoods than anything downtown. Four hundred-plus reviews is enough to rule out a fluke, and the gap between it and the bigger names is one of sample size, not quality. A reasonable pick when the downtown parking situation is not worth the trouble.
4. Bicyclette Cookshop
A 4.6 rating across 626 reviews, at 819 Vanderbilt Beach Rd, which makes it the most convenient entry for anyone staying at the north end near Vanderbilt Beach. The name signals a cookshop rather than a burger counter, so the burger sits on a broader menu, useful if the group is split on what it wants. The review base is mid-sized: substantial enough to trust, not so large that the score is immovable. There is a website listed if you want to check the current menu and hours before going.
5. Midnight Tavern
Tavern territory at 2800 Davis Blvd, holding 4.5 from 556 reviews. Davis Boulevard is a working stretch of road rather than a scenic one, which tends to keep the crowd local and the wait shorter than anything closer to the water. The rating is consistent with the other taverns here, and the sample is large enough to be meaningful. Best treated as a late-in-the-day option rather than a lunch stop, given the name and the setting. Its site lists current details, worth a look if you are planning around a specific evening.
6. Jimmy P's Charred - Naples
The thinnest evidence on the list, and stated plainly: 4.4 from 191 reviews, the lowest score and the smallest sample here. That combination means the rating could still move in either direction. The address, 1839 Tamiami Trl N, puts it on the Trail just north of the downtown core, an easy add-on if you are already heading that way. Charred is a steakhouse-adjacent format, so this is the entry for anyone who wants a burger in a meat-focused kitchen rather than a tavern. Worth trying, but the other five have more reviews behind them.