Best Pizza in Naples, Florida
Naples, Florida — updated August 21, 2026
Eight Naples pizzerias ranked by how well they answer the question, from a Tamiami Trail beer-and-pie kitchen with more than 1,300 reviews to a square-pie shop on Vanderbilt Beach Road.
Listings verified
Naples shares a name with the city that invented the pizza, which sets an unfair bar, and the local answer is mostly not Neapolitan at all: New York-style slice counters, square and grandma pies, and beer-forward kitchens strung along Tamiami Trail. The other thing worth knowing before you drive is hours. Several of the best rooms here do not open until mid-afternoon on weekdays, and one of them closes at five.
1. LowBrow Pizza & Beer
The most tested pizza reputation in Naples: a 4.6 average across more than 1,300 reviews, which is a settled number rather than an early one. It sits at 3148 Tamiami Trail E, pairing pies with a beer list. Plan around the schedule, because the kitchen keeps late-start weekday hours — Monday through Thursday it opens at 4pm, with earlier openings Friday through Sunday. Mondays were added at some point and run 4pm to 9pm. Reservations are taken only for parties of eight or more, and only before 5pm, so a weekend dinner for two means walking in and waiting.
2. Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew
A 4.7 across 547 reviews puts it a notch above LowBrow on rating with roughly half the evidence behind it, which is still a substantial sample. Like several places on this list it is a pizza-and-beer operation rather than a white-tablecloth trattoria. The hours are the thing to memorize: Sunday through Thursday it opens at 3pm and closes at 9pm, so there is no weekday lunch. Friday and Saturday it opens at 11:30am, which are the only two days you can get a pie there before mid-afternoon.
3. San Giuseppe Pizza
The highest rating on the list with a meaningful count behind it: 4.8 from 452 reviews, in a strip location at 2400 Vanderbilt Beach Rd #104. The menu is built around variety of shape as much as topping, listing round pizzas, square pizzas and stuffed pizzas alongside calzones and strombolis. The grandma pie draws specific praise in the shop's own posted reviews. Ordering is set up online through Slice, which makes this the easier pick when you want a pie to carry back to a rental rather than a table for the evening.
4. Luigi's Pizza
New York-style, at 2331 Tamiami Trail E, holding a 4.6 across 360 reviews. The shop makes the point that everything from lasagna to meatballs is prepared fresh daily, and subs share the menu with pizza. Two practical notes. First, hours run short at the start of the week: Monday is listed at 11am to 2pm, with Tuesday through Thursday running 11am to 8pm. Second, the shop states that its own site, LuigisofNaples.net, is the only place it posts prices and that those prices are current — useful given how many third-party menus float around.
5. The Crust Pizza Naples
A 4.5 over roughly 1,200 reviews, which is the second-largest body of evidence here and the reason it outranks some higher-rated shops. The premise is stated plainly on their own site: pizza, subs and salads, nothing else, on the grounds that a menu should not be a book. The Naples address is 8004 Trail Blvd, north of downtown, with Yelp listing 11am to 9pm at the start of the week; the restaurant points customers to Google for current hours, so check before a late run.
6. Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria
A full Italian kitchen at 4910 Tamiami Trail N #124 that also sells pizza by the slice every day, which is rarer in Naples than it should be. The rating is 4.8, but from 249 reviews — promising rather than proven, and worth reading as an early signal. Lunch specials run daily from 11am to 3pm, and dinner specials are limited to Thursday through Saturday from 4pm until close, so the day you go changes what is on offer. Lasagna is among the dishes the restaurant is known for.
7. Baci Trattoria & Pizza
The trattoria option: 2740 Bayshore Dr, 4.4 from 750 reviews, with pizza sharing the menu with fried calamari, rice balls and linguini with clam sauce. Both a margherita and a grandma pie appear on the pizza list. The rating is the lowest here, but it comes from a large enough sample to be reliable, and the draw is a sit-down Italian dinner where the pizza is competent rather than a slice shop. Listings show a 10am opening early in the week; one source indicates it is closed Sundays, so confirm before a weekend plan.
8. Neapolitan Gourmet
Included with a caveat. This is an Italian shop at 5415 Airport-Pulling Rd that sells groceries alongside prepared food, not a dinner pizzeria, and it closes at 5pm — the hours run 10am to 5pm, which rules it out for evening. It holds a 4.7 from 232 reviews, the thinnest evidence base on this list, so treat the score as encouraging rather than established. The counter menu leans toward heroes, including roast beef and provolone and an American combo, with cannoli and Italian cookies sold by the pound.
What we left off
Two multi-location operations were cut to keep this to independent Naples kitchens. Aurelio's Pizza of Naples on Naples Blvd is a franchise of a chain operating since 1959 across several states. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza on Vanderbilt Beach Rd is likewise part of a group with locations beyond Florida, including Dallas, despite its strong 4.7 rating from more than 1,100 reviews. Both serve pizza in Naples; neither is a Naples-only business.