Best Pizza Places in Naples
Naples, Florida — updated August 22, 2026
Six Naples pizzerias ranked by what the reviews actually support, from a 72-hour fermented thin crust on Vanderbilt Beach Road to New York slices on Tamiami Trail.
Listings verified
Naples pizza clusters along two roads: Tamiami Trail, where the East Trail stretch south of downtown holds most of the slice counters and beer-forward pizzerias, and Vanderbilt Beach Road up north. The gap between the two big names here is instructive: one has a 4.6 average across more than 1,300 reviews, the other a 4.7 across more than 1,100, and both are settled numbers rather than early enthusiasm. Below, the highest ratings with the thinnest review counts come last, not first.
1. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza - Naples
The dough is the argument here: a thin crust made with a light dough that rests a minimum of 72 hours, and up to 96, in natural fermentation before it is stretched. That process is stated on the menu itself, not inferred. The rating is 4.7 across 1,114 reviews, which is enough volume to treat as proven rather than promising. Pizzas run 13 inches, with traditional and special versions plus a Nutella pizza on the sweet end. The Vanderbilt Beach Road location keeps to 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Sunday through Thursday and stays open until 10:00 PM Friday and Saturday.
2. LowBrow Pizza & Beer
The most-reviewed pizzeria on this list, at 4.6 from 1,307 reviews, which makes it the safest bet in Naples for a first-timer. It sits on the East Trail stretch of Tamiami, and the hours matter more than usual: Monday through Thursday it does not open until 4:00 PM, while Friday through Sunday service starts around midday. Mondays were a recent addition to the schedule. Groups are handled carefully, with reservations for parties of eight or more accepted only before 5:00 PM, so a large table showing up at seven should expect to wait.
3. San Giuseppe Pizza
The broadest pizza menu of the six: round pies, square pizza and stuffed pizza all appear separately, alongside calzones, strombolis, sandwiches and salads. The grandma pie draws specific praise in reviews posted to the restaurant's own site. Its 4.8 average comes from 452 reviews, a strong showing though a smaller sample than the two places above it. House favorites include a meat lovers pizza with sausage. Ordering is set up to run online, which is the practical choice given the Vanderbilt Beach Road plaza location and the takeout traffic it draws.
4. Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew
A 4.7 average from 547 reviews puts this one in genuinely well-tested territory, above the small-sample range where a high score can still move. The name signals the format, pizza with beer, and the address is the East Trail run of Tamiami where LowBrow also sits, so the two make an easy comparison on separate nights. Beyond the rating and the location, the brief carries no menu detail, hours or house specialties, so treat the specifics as unconfirmed and check before driving out. The review volume is the reason it ranks here.
5. Luigi's Pizza
New York-style pizza, with lasagna and meatballs made fresh daily, from a small Tamiami Trail East storefront. The rating is 4.6 from 360 reviews. Hours are the thing to plan around: Monday is lunch only, roughly 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM, while Tuesday through Thursday runs 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM. Luigi's also states that its own website is the only place it posts menu prices and that those prices are kept current, which is worth knowing if you have seen figures listed on third-party delivery pages. Subs round out the menu.
6. Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria
The place to go when you want one slice rather than a whole pie: Bruno's serves pizza by the slice daily. It carries a 4.8 average, the joint highest here, but from 249 reviews, so read that as promising rather than settled. Daily lunch specials run 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM, and dinner specials are limited to Thursday through Saturday from 4:00 PM until close, which makes the midweek evening a different, quieter proposition. Lasagna is among the dishes reviewers name. The address is on Tamiami Trail North, closer to the middle of town than the East Trail cluster.